When Harry Became Sally: A Book Review

When Harry Became Sally: A Book Review is a must read for anyone interested in the transgender movement. It offers a well-reasoned, compassionate exploration of the issues at stake.

Checkout this video:


When Harry Became Sally: Review
In When Harry Became Sally: Responding to the Transgender Moment, Ryan T. Anderson offers a thoughtful and level-headed approach to one of the most controversial issues of our time. With compassion and reason, he challenges the beliefs that have become accepted as orthodoxy in recent years, and he does so without demonizing those who disagree with him.

Anderson begins by examining the transgender movement’s major claims about gender identity. He shows how these claims are at odds with both science and common sense, and he explains why they should not be enshrined in law. He then turns to the practical consequences of accepting these claims, showing how they would harm women, undermine parental rights, and erase meaningful distinctions between men and women.

This is a timely and important book that is sure to be controversial. But it is also a gracious and fair-minded book, one that is sure to start much needed conversations about one of the most divisive issues of our time.

The Book’s Main Thesis

The book’s main thesis is that there are two groups of people in the world when it comes to how they view transgenderism: the reality-based group, and the fantasy-based group. The reality-based group includes people who understand that transgenderism is a real thing, and that trans people are just people who happen to be transgender. The fantasy-based group includes people who think that transgenderism is a choice, or that it’s just a phase, or that trans people are trying to trick others by pretending to be the opposite gender.

The book goes into detail about how the reality-based group and the fantasy-based group view transgenderism differently, and how this affects both trans people and society as a whole. It also debunks some of the myths about transgenderism that are commonly believed by the fantasy-based group. Overall, it’s an informative and thought-provoking read.

Detailed Review of the Book

Book Description:

When Harry Became Sally: Understanding Transgenderism and Our Culture’s Shift in Acceptance is a book by Ryan T. Anderson released in early 2018. It is a well researched examination of the transgender movement and its implications. Written in a calm and reasonable tone, the book covers a lot of ground on the topic, including the science (or lack thereof) behind transgenderism, the stories of those who have transitioned and then “de-transitioned”, the impact on children, women’s rights, and more.

It’s a detailed and insightful read that is bound to be controversial. Whether you agree or disagree with Anderson’s conclusions, this book is sure to get you thinking about one of today’s most hot-button issues.

My Thoughts:

I found this book to be extremely thought-provoking. I was not familiar with many of the studies cited or the stories shared, so it was eye-opening in that regard. Anderson makes a very compelling case against transgenderism, particularly when it comes to children. He presents the data in an unbiased way and lets the reader make up their own mind.

There were parts of the book that I did not agree with, such as Anderson’s view on gender roles (he believes they are natural and essential), but overall I found it to be a well-reasoned and thought-provoking examination of an important topic.

The Book’s Reception

When Harry Became Sally: A Book Review
The book When Harry Became Sally: A Book Review, by Ryan T. Anderson, was published in early 2018. In it, the author reviews different scientific studies on sex and gender, and argues that one’s sex is determined by biology, not by gender identity.

The book was generally well-received by reviewers. Many praised Anderson for his fair and even-handed approach to a complex and controversial topic. However, some reviewers criticized the book for its alleged lack of objectivity, and for its failure to consider the lived experiences of transgender people.

The Implications of the Book

It is impossible to read When Harry Became Sally without being moved by the individual stories that Deborah Soh skillfully weaves together. But the book is not just a collection of sad tales. Soh uses her protagonists’ unique experiences to explore some of the most controversial and emotionally charged issues of our time.

In When Harry Became Sally, Soh offers a well-reasoned and level-headed exploration of the implications of the transgender movement. She challenges many of the commonly held assumptions about gender and transgenderism, and forces readers to confront their own preconceptions.

Soh’s book will likely be divisive, but it is also an important contribution to the ongoing conversation about gender and identity.

The Broader Context of the Book

In “When Harry Became Sally: Responding to the Transgender Moment,” Ryan T. Anderson offers a thoughtful and level-headed challenge to the transgender movement’s reinterpretation of sex and gender. Anderson, a conservative Christian and a research fellow at the Heritage Foundation, is troubled by what he sees as an assault on the biological basis of sex differences and a capitulation to gender ideology. He is also alarmed by the growing push to medicalize gender-dysphoric children and teens with puberty blockers, cross-sex hormones, and ultimately, sex-reassignment surgery.

While Anderson is sympathetic to the plight of individuals with gender dysphoria, he insists that we cannot redefine sex or ignore the fact that there are only two sexes. Drawing on biology, sociology, philosophy, and psychology, he makes a reasoned case against efforts to mainstream transgenderism. He also offers thoughtful guidance on how to respond graciously and compassionately to friends or family members who identify as transgender.

Those who are already familiar with the transgender movement’s arguments will find little that is new in Anderson’s book. However, his clear and concise presentation of the conservative perspective will be valuable for anyone who wants to engage thoughtfully with this controversial issue.

The Significance of the Book

The book “When Harry Became Sally: Responding to the Transgender Moment” by Ryan T. Anderson is a very important book because it challenges the transgender movement’s ideology that everyone’s inner “gender identity” should trump their biological sex.

The Book’s Contribution to the Debate

In “When Harry Became Sally”, Ryan T. Anderson makes a persuasive case that sex is determined at birth and cannot be changed. He reviews the scientific evidence, discusses the social implications, and argues that policies that allow people to change their legal sex are harmful.

Anderson’s book is an important contribution to the debate over transgender rights. His clear and accessible writing makes complex topics easy to understand, and his fair-minded approach will appeal to readers on both sides of the issue. However, those who are already committed to the transgender rights agenda is likely to find his arguments unpersuasive.

The Book’s Limitations

The book’s limitations are primarily due to its thesis. As a work of philosophy, the book is reductionist, focusing narrowly on gender identity rather than the many other factors that contribute to a person’s sense of self. This narrowness is both a strength and a weakness. It allows the author to develop his argument in great detail, but it also means that he often oversimplifies complex issues.

As a work of history, the book is also limited. The author relies heavily on secondary sources, and he includes very few first-person accounts from transgender people themselves. This makes it difficult to get a sense of the lived experiences of transgender people, and it also makes it difficult to verify the accuracy of the author’s claims.


It is easy to see why many people would find When Harry Became Sally: A Book Review thought-provoking and insightful. transgenderism is a controversial topic, and this book provides a well-reasoned, respectful exploration of the subject. It is clear that author Ryan T. Anderson has done his research, and he has presented his findings in a fair and balanced manner. However, some readers may find the book’s overall tone to be too sympathetic to the transgender perspective, and they may take issue with Anderson’s suggestion that children should not be given hormone therapy or surgery to transition to the opposite sex. Overall, When Harry Became Sally is a well-written and informative book that will be of interest to readers on both sides of the transgender debate.

Scroll to Top